# Thursday, July 12, 2007

So very confusing

Muslims are taking over San Diego!

Here's what I'm confused about:

  1. 7th and 8th grade in an elementary school? (Seems unlikely)
  2. Is it a "period" an "hour" or "15 minutes"? Islamic prayer generally takes about 5 minutes, 1 hour seems a bit over the top.
  3. The teacher claims "Ms. -" lead the prayer, but that isn't consistent with Islamic tradition, and she left before anything even began.
  4. The American flag was "rolled up"? Why the would any Muslim do that?
  5. Why is closing the blinds without direction so unnerving? If you do anything on a daily basis, wouldn't kids just do it?
  6. Has anyone heard of any Muslim complaining about Catholics "doing" rosaries ever?
  7. Assimilations? How is changing your religious practices "assimilation"? I wasn't aware that being American was a religion.
  8. Doesn't everyone understand yet that Arab does not equal Muslim? And they can't remotely be interchanged?

I also see that the 2006 enrollment was 290 and they state in the story that there is "100 Muslim students" or more than 1/3 of the school, and according to their ethnic breakdown it seems impossible that those 100 Muslim students were "Arabic".

When did people stop learning the details before freaking out? I remember a day when it was considered good practice to check sources and site references, and I long for that day to return.

Update: Apparently in September a nearby "charter" school was merged with Carver and that charter school had an Arabic immersion program. Apparently it happened days before the school opened, and they had no chance to update the curriculum or syllabus. And apparently it is a predominately Somali (not Arab) student population [ San Diego Union-Tribune ]. Apparently the class is all female as well, so my points 1, 2, and 3 above are all cleared up and now make sense. It also seems that the student population has grown to 415 [ Union-Tribune ] due to this merger so we're talking about 1/4 of the school being Muslim.

Update: On the Religion Clause website there are a few comments that I find hard to believe, are there really places in this country where the students are forbidden to say "God" or "Jesus" or carry a bible? In my high-school in an English class we studied the language used in the bible by using bibles that the school owns. I can't imagine that my schooling experience was that radically different (though I have just moved back into Montgomery Country because of the excellent school system). I would recommend anyone who has their child arrested for carrying a bible to school move and move quickly.

#    Comments [2] |
Friday, July 13, 2007 11:08:31 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
Actually, yes, I think I can believe people would get in trouble for carrying a bible and so forth. Even when I was in high school (in Texas -- over 10 years ago) there was a big to-do about a group that got together before school on a voluntary basis to pray. I believe they eventually won, since it was completely on their own time and such, but I find it amazing anyone could have thought there was a problem with it.

I'm pretty sure teachers in certain schools (if not all) would have trouble with studying passages from the Bible these days.

A lot of people misinterpret the idea of "separation of church and state" and don't realize that forbidding people from praying would be a violation of their rights.

This is a substitute teacher who can't understand that 7th graders can close blinds by themselves? Ooookay.

kaite
Friday, July 13, 2007 11:15:07 AM (Eastern Standard Time, UTC-05:00)
Crazy talk. Yet another reason I like where I live. The only stories I've seen lately w/r/t religion in Montgomery County are how well interfaith activities have been working. I guess it helps to live in a Catholic colony founded for religious freedom and abundant with the multiverse of religious adherents.
Comments are closed.